| Platinum | Skyway Jack's Restaurant |
| Gold | Kristina's Cafe |
| Silver | Kissin' Cuzzins Neighborhood |
| Bronze | Egg Haven Cafe |
| Top Pick | Harvey's 4th Street Grill |
| Top Pick | Heavenly Donuts Sweets & Eats |
| Top Pick | Stella's |
| Top Pick | The Frog Pond Downtown St. Petersburg |
| St. Pete Bagel Co |