| Platinum | Gateway Subs |
| Gold | Localz |
| Silver | Stone Soup Cafe |
| Bronze | Roe's Cafe and Catering |
| Top Pick | Decosmo Italian Market |
| Top Pick | Jo-El's Specialty Foods |
| Top Pick | The Chattaway |
| Fourth Street Shrimp Store | |
| St. Pete Bagel Co | |
| The Frog Pond Downtown St. Petersburg |