| Platinum | Cappy’s Pizza |
| Platinum | Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza |
| Gold | Oak & Stone |
| Silver | Derussos Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Paulo's Pizza and Subs |
| Top Pick | Decosmo Italian Market |
| Top Pick | Flippers Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Franca's Pizza Catering |
| Gratzzi Italian Grille |