| Platinum | Mazzaro's Italian Market |
| Gold | Hello Sweetie Sweets |
| Silver | Cake Affection |
| Bronze | Cafe Soleil |
| Top Pick | A Special Touch Cakes by Carolyn |
| Top Pick | Cafe Clementine |
| Top Pick | Decosmo Italian Market |
| Top Pick | Mama G's German Bakery and Coffeehouse |
| Top Pick | Pete's Bagels |
| Top Pick | Wandering Whisk |